Wednesday, October 14, 2009

The new and not-so-improved Illinois offense

The most puzzling thing to me about Illinois' putrid 1-4 start is the rapid decline of the offense.  The rushing offense has been somewhat disappointing, but is really in the same place it was last year (4.6 yards per carry in 2009 vs. 4.4 in 2008).  The drop-off, then, has been in the passing game, which has plummeted from a stellar 8.2 yards per attempt to a mediocre 5.9.  I still don't have a satisfying explanation for why this might be, so let's try a few theories:

1.  The offensive line


Ron Zook called out the offensive line after the Michigan State game for its poor play.  I certainly believe that the play of the offensive line is every bit as important, if not more so, to the success of an offense as the play of its quarterback.  Thus, a lot of Illinois' struggles may stem from having lost two senior starters from last year's line (Ryan McDonald and Xavier Fulton).  That said, losing two starters, although a significant loss, shouldn't necessarily have crippled the line.  But it clearly has.





As has been documented on Football Outsiders, some quarterbacks take more sacks than others, regardless of the quality of their offensive line.  But with the same quarterbacks on the field last year, Illinois allowed just 25 sacks in 12 games.  Through 5 games this year, they have already allowed 19.  Not only do the sacks hurt by themselves, but they are an indicator that Juice and Eddie are facing a lot more pressure than they were last year, which undoubtedly hurts their productivity even on plays where they aren't getting sacked.

2.  The change in offensive coordinators

After Mike Locksley left to become the head coach at New Mexico, Ron Zook hired Mike Schultz from TCU to become the new offensive coordinator.  Although I was impressed with Locksley's ability to change from a run-first to a pass-first offense without any loss in productivity after the departure of Rashard Mendenhall, I was also optimistic about Schultz since he came from a winning mid-major program in TCU.  Unfortunately, I overlooked that TCU has been a strong program primarily because of its defense, and the offense was only passable under Schultz, ranking an average of 56th nationally in yards per play from 2004-2008.

Since Schultz's offenses at TCU were usually complemented by great defenses, it was to his advantage to play a conservative style.  Yet Illinois' strength last year was taking shots downfield.  Locksley wisely took advantage of Juice's arm strength and realized his inaccuracy would hinder an offense built around short passes.  But look what has happened this year:




The deep pass game has disappeared.  Now there are a lot of reasons this could be the case, including the poor play of the offensive line, and Arrelious Benn struggling with injuries.  Yet from my own observation,  Schultz has been calling significantly fewer deep pass plays than Locksley.  The Eddie McGee experiment was doomed before it even began because Schultz went even more conservative, running on first and second down and then throwing on third and long.  The playbook only opened up once Juice came in and the team was hopelessly behind.

3. Arrelious Benn playing hurt

As I've detailed in earlier posts, this has been another huge factor in the decline of the offense.  After putting up 1055 yards last year, Benn is on pace for just 422 this year after suffering an injury that took him out of the game against Missouri and rendered him ineffective against Illinois State.  He finally was starting to get in the swing of things against Penn State, with 5 catches for 96 yards, only to suffer a concussion against Michigan State and be held to 38 yards on 3 catches.  Benn is a phenomenally talented receiver and it was his ability to get open and adjust to Juice's errant throws that allowed Juice to be successful in the passing game in 2008 despite his lack of accuracy.

When I started this post, I really wasn't sure what to blame for the decline of the Illinois offense.  I don't think any one of the above three factors is solely responsible, but combined, they have resulted in a huge hit on the team's effectiveness.  The good news is that most of these things can be corrected.  If Benn stays healthy, he will undoubtedly begin to produce closer to 2008 levels.  I suspect this will also let Schultz concentrate on the deep ball a bit more.  Finally, the offensive line is young and Zook has been experimenting with different line combinations to find the right mix.  The offense has hit rock-bottom and can only go up from here.  The question is whether it will improve enough to allow the Illini to escape the Big 10 basement.

Monday, October 12, 2009

Michigan State 24, Illinois 14


The vibe among Illinois fans after the game was rightly one of despair.  Matt Hinton at Dr. Saturday went as far as to say that that Illinois is "closing in on Washington State as the worst 'Big Six' conference team in the country."  The reactions aren't surprising considering Michigan State dominated the first half and the game wasn't even as close as the 17-0 halftime score indicated given that the Spartans had a fumble on the goal line and another drive that stalled out in Illinois territory.

At the half, Michigan State had outgained Illinois 282-60, averaged 6.7 yards per play to Illinois' 3.3, and ran 42 plays to 18 by Illinois.  Domination in every sense.  And after Eddie McGee threw an interception that was returned for a touchdown, the game was more or less over at 24-0.  Yet the final score and statistics wound up looking not so bad as the Illini outplayed the Spartans significantly in the second half:


The obvious reaction is to say that the game was over in the second half.  But it wasn't, necessarily.  The defense legitimately played much better in the second half, and although the offense was still scuffling until a 4 play, 67 yard touchdown drive near the end, the team played better once McGee was pulled for Juice.  Yeah, it's not much to go off of.  But considering some of my friends and family are forecasting a 1-11 season for Illinois, the second half performance is an indication, to me at least, that things aren't that hopeless yet.  Some signs of life are better than none at all, and some signs of life put Illinois a long way ahead of Washington State.

Friday, October 9, 2009

Illini Outlook and MSU Pick

On this cool site, you can track how the line setters at Vegas are ranking each college football team based on the weekly spreads.  Illinois has been plummeting through the rankings, but they are still seen as a team with enough talent to rank 51st nationally.  More importantly, these rankings allowed me to generate some prospective lines for the rest of the season:

Illinois (+6) at Indiana
Illinois at Purdue (-2)
Michigan (+1.5) at Illinois
Illinois at Minnesota (-3)
Northwestern at Illinois (-6.5)
Illinois at Cincinnati (-11.5)
Fresno State at Illinois (-4.5)

(+x denotes a road favorite; -x a home favorite - so Illinois projects to be favored at Indiana, and at home against Northwestern and Fresno State)

Of course, having acquired some prospective lines, I really got going and using odds generated from projected money lines, I simulated 1000 Illinois seasons to see what their prognosis is.  Here are the results:

9-3: 0
8-4: 19
7-5: 94
6-6: 239
5-7: 302
4-8: 221
3-9: 96
2-10: 27
1-11: 2

Clearly Illinois isn't going to win out, but fans shouldn't fear that the team won't be winning any more games this year.  In fact, the team will likely finish at least 4-8 with a mean projection of 5-7.  A bowl berth is not yet out of reach either, with their odds of finishing 6-6 or higher at 35.2%.  Good news for Ron Zook - if the team does finish 5-7, he probably won't lose his job, at least not this season.

This weekend's game is as good a time as any for Illinois to start making a late run.  For all his deficiencies, I admire Zook for being willing to take a chance and start Eddie McGee at quarterback.  The team is more likely to miss a bowl than make one at this point, so it is worth seeing if McGee can spark the Illini offense.  Michigan State is a stronger team than their record indicates, but if Illinois wins tomorrow, their odds of making a bowl increase to 49.5% in my simulation and potentially higher since a win would positively impact future lines.  I am still going to pick against Illinois until they prove me wrong with a win, but this analysis has made me more optimistic about the future of the season.

Pick: Michigan State 27, Illinois 21

Thursday, October 8, 2009

Michigan State Preview


Last year's Michigan State team had a successful season, going 6-2 in conference and 9-4 overall. Give some credit to coach Mark Dantonio for taking a team that wasn't all that talented (45-7 and 49-18 losses to Ohio State and Penn State) but taking care of business against all of the teams that were of MSU's caliber. Then again, winning close games doesn't always carry over from year to year, and this year the Spartans, after an easy win against Montana State, lost games by 2,3,and 8 points, before finally prevailing in overtime against Michigan last Saturday. Michigan State was actually outgained on a per-play basis last year (5.3 to 4.9) and still went 9-4 while this year they have substantially outgained their opponents (6.3 to 5.0) and are just 2-3.

This year's squad, despite losing workhorse running back Javon Ringer (1637 yards in 2008), is actually improved on offense thanks to putting more emphasis on a rejuvenated passing game under QBs Kirk Cousins and Keith Nichol. Although I'm skeptical that running Ringer into the ground last year (390 carries) was a good idea in the first place, it is a sign of a well-coached team that MSU has adapted to different personnel this year. An average passing game has been replaced by a very good one with Cousins and Nichol both averaging over 8 yards per pass attempt. Nichol is the greater running threat but both have positive rushing yardage, something which MSU could not say last year with immobile QB Brian Hoyer (-94 rushing yards). Although a clear #1 running back has yet to emerge, the ground game hasn't been that much less effective than the 2008 version and has been called upon less heavily.

In terms of points per game, the defense has been less effective this year, but it in fact has done pretty well on a per-play basis despite going up against some stiff competition. Central Michigan put up more yards than MSU but also ran 20 more plays in its 29-27 victory. The Spartans held an explosive Notre Dame attack to 6.2 yards per play but were -1 in turnovers and wound up losing by a field goal. Finally, Wisconsin averaged just 5.4 yards per play but wound up winning thanks to a +3 performance in turnovers.

Overall, this looks like a better team than their win-loss record would indicate. They dropped the ball against Central Michigan but performed well against a tough slate of teams in their next 3 games and could easily have gone 3-0 in that stretch. This is why despite only being one game ahead of Illinois in the standings and going on the road, the Spartans are a 3.5 point favorite. Tomorrow, I will examine the match-up from Illinois' side and make my prediction.

Monday, October 5, 2009

Your new starting quarterback - Eddie McGee!

In a surprising move, Ron Zook has named Eddie McGee the starting quarterback for Illinois this weekend against Michigan State. My girlfriend is in full support of the change, but I worry that McGee won't really add anything to the offense. I am well aware of Juice's flaws but he also hasn't gotten enough credit for his fine junior season because of the team's 5-7 record. Despite losing Rashard Mendenhall to the NFL Draft (who, might I add, ran for 162 yards and 2 touchdowns on national television last night), the Illinois offense scored more points and gained more yards per game in 2008 than in 2007. This was largely because the passing game was much improved, as Juice averaged 8.3 yards per pass attempt and threw for 3173 yards.

All that said, Juice's numbers are down this year (5.8 ypa) and Eddie McGee forever won the hearts of Illinois fans when he came off the bench and was a goal-line interception away from leading a big comeback against an 11-2 Missouri team in 2007. My main concern is that although McGee has been very good for a backup, he appears to be the same kind of player as Juice:





Over the last three years McGee's production when he has played has been comparable to Juice's. What concerns me is that while McGee, like Juice, has been productive in terms of generating yardage, he shares the same proclivities for low completion percentages and high interception rates. In fact, although the sample size is small, McGee's completion percentage has been lower and his interception rate higher.

Given McGee's nice career yards per attempt figure, a QB switch isn't a totally crazy idea. But I fear that if McGee is no more or less productive than Juice has been, it will undermine the leadership of this team. The question is whether Illinois at 1-3 is already at the point where they need to try something radical to salvage the season. Despite my qualms, the answer may be yes, but I wonder if Zook is pulling the plug on his productive senior starter too soon.

Technorati Tags:, , ,
Generated By Technorati Tag Generator

Sunday, October 4, 2009

Penn State 35, Illinois 17


My optimistic forecasting was in some ways, pretty accurate for this game. Illinois rediscovered their future NFL wide receiver Arrelious Benn, who had 5 catches for 96 yards. Juice threw for 263 yards, averaging a respectable 7.3 yards per attempt. The Illini were competitive throughout the first half and could have been down 7-6 or even ahead 10-7 at the half had a late drive not stalled out due to penalties.

All that said, the utter dominance of Penn State in the third quarter was a harsh reminder that Illinois, right now, is not a very good football team. Ahead just 7-3 at the half, Penn State embarked on consecutive drives of 55, 69, 79, and 80 yards, the first drive ending in a fumble, but the next three ending in rushing touchdowns. Illinois wound up with a respectable 393 yards of offense against a strong defense, but 150 of that (and 14 of their points) came once Penn State had already seized a commanding 28-3 lead, and they put up just 8 yards of offense in the critical third quarter.

In my game preview, I had highlighted Penn State's rushing offense as a team weakness, but you would never have known it from watching this game. The Nittany Lions ran for 338 yards on 40 attempts and simply ran the ball over and over again in the second half to little resistance from the Illinois front. Considering that Illinois produced just 130 yards on the ground, this was the difference in the game. Illinois wasn't flagged for a lot of penalties and their two turnovers were forgivable considering they came on a Hail Mary pass at the end of the first half and after the game was already over at 28-10, but the disparity on the ground was too much to overcome.

At 1-3, Illinois has made it through the toughest portion of their schedule but has shown little to suggest that the results will improve against the easier portion of their schedule. A bowl bid is not completely unrealistic yet, but it is looking less and less likely with each passing week.

Friday, October 2, 2009

Penn State at Illinois, Preview

In my previous post, I detailed some of the reasons Illinois might not be as bad as they have looked and why they might be primed for a stronger performance this weekend. Unfortunately, they are playing a superior Penn State team that will also be up after an unexpected 21-10 home loss to Iowa.

What do we know about Penn State after the first four weeks? They cruised against three creampuffs in Akron, Syracuse and Temple (though Syracuse is looking more lively this year) and then were ambushed by a strong Iowa team which dominated on defense and on the ground. First off, their offense may not be as strong as anticipated. They are averaging 7.3 yards per pass attempt (56th nationally) after averaging 8.3 last year (15th) despite a soft non-conference schedule. They have really struggled on the ground, (3.8 yards per carry; 73rd nationally), again, after a much stronger showing last year (5.2 ypc; 12th).

The struggles of PSU's offense this year are a good reminder that there is more to an offense than just quarterback and running back. Penn State's offensive line starters this year are all either brand new or are starting at a different position. Meanwhile, Penn State graduated its top three receivers in Deon Butler, Jordan Norwood, and Derrick Williams. As such, QB Daryll Clark has been good but not spectacular and RB Evan Royster has struggled to run as effectively behind a reworked offensive line. These problems weren't as a big of a deal during their nonconference schedule, but Iowa was able to put constant pressure on Clark and plug up the running holes for Royster.

That said, Penn State's defense has mostly been excellent, allowing just 41 points in four games. They have been pretty good, but not great, against the pass, ranking 34th nationally at 5.8 yards per attempt allowed. But they have been spectacular against the run, allowing just 2.4 yards per carry, ranking 11th in the country.

The strength of Penn State's defense is bad news for an Illinois offense licking its wounds. Yet there is reason for hope. Star MLB Sean Lee won't be suiting up for the Nittany Lions after also missing the Iowa game with a knee injury. Without Lee and facing a more respectable run game, Penn State gave up 163 rushing yards against Iowa, at 4.4 yards per carry. Furthermore, Penn State has a good but not great pass defense, so there will be opportunities to get the ball to Arrelious Benn.

Prediction: A jacked up Illinois team makes some plays early through the air as Arrelious Benn goes over 100 receiving yards for the first time this season but an ineffectual running game is unable to get going even without Sean Lee there to stuff the run. After experiencing some troubles early against a solid Illinois pass rush, Daryll Clark begins to carve up the Illini secondary in the second half. Illinois hangs around but feels the season beginning to slip away as Clark leads a backbreaking yard touchdown drive to put Penn State up by two scores in the fourth quarter.

Final score: Penn State 28, Illinois 17