Friday, October 23, 2009

Purdue Outlook and Bonus UNC Coverage


Since forecasting Illinois games is becoming ever more depressing, I am going to supplement this post with some bonus North Carolina football coverage in honor of my girlfriend, who now attends UNC.  Needless to say, there will be no bonus UNC basketball coverage but I feel there are no conflicts of interest when it comes to football.

Last night was a desperation game for both Florida State and North Carolina who each entered the season with high expectations but were both off to 0-2 starts in the ACC.  Unfortunately for the Heels, they are now 0-3 in ACC play after FSU rallied from an 18 point second-half deficit to win 30-27.  It was an interesting game going in, as UNC was 1st in defense, but 110th in offense (in terms of yards per play) while FSU was 25th in offense, 115th in defense (again in terms of yards per play).  In the first half, the Heels defense won out and the offense took advantage of short-field situations for scores but in the second half QB Christian Ponder took over for Florida State while the UNC offense flatlined.

Betsy won't like this, but ultimately the statistics show that Florida State probably should have won by more than 3 points, despite the 18-point deficit.  Not only were their offense much more explosive on a per-play basis (6.8 to 4.9) but they were also were more consistent as shown by success rate (46.2% to 30.9%).  The Heels were solid on the ground, running some end-around and reverse plays to great effect, but did almost nothing through the air.  Meanwhile, after a penalty-ridden first half, Florida State lit up the UNC defense in the second half for 338 yards and 23 successes on just 40 plays.  The Seminoles never established a running threat but Christian Ponder nonetheless threw for 395 yards. 

Unfortunately, UNC has a tough slate of games coming up with the only potential breather being a November 7 home game against Duke.  They can still reel off some wins but they will need to bring a consistent effort on defense and have their offense take advantage of short-field situations as it did against Florida State.  The stats from last night's game look bad, but I think the real problem was that the team simply let up after going ahead 24-6 in the third quarter.  It's natural, but given their offensive deficiencies, it can't afford to happen.

Well, my bonus UNC coverage wound up consuming the entire post.  But suffice it to say, I'm returning to my strategy of picking against the Illini until they prove to me that I shouldn't.

Pick: Purdue 35, Illinois 17

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Illinois at Purdue, Preview

Before last weekend, I optimistically envisioned this game as the second consecutive win in a mid-season turnaround for the Illini.  If Illinois managed to beat Indiana, they would then be playing a 1-6 Purdue team.  Except, of course, Illinois lost and Purdue isn't 1-6 after a shocking 26-18 home upset of Ohio State.  Now, Illinois is a 10 point underdog against the suddenly resurgent Boilermakers.

All that said, I disagree with Dr. Saturday's contention that "it's not like Purdue was a snake in the grass or anything."  I certainly would not have picked Purdue to beat Ohio State just because Ohio State has historically been so reliable against its Big 10 opponents.  But Purdue was absolutely better than their 1-5 record going in indicated and are better than their current 2-5 mark as well.  They lost by just 2 points on the road against Oregon (#11 in the BCS standings) and by 3 at home against Notre Dame.  On the other hand, they did have head-scratching losses against Northern Illinois, Northwestern and to a lesser extent, Minnesota.  The NIU loss was legitimately head-scratching but the Northwestern loss was a fluke, as Purdue outgained the Wildcats by over 3 yards per play but was -5 in turnover margin.  Even the 15 point loss to Minnesota was closer than it appeared as the teams were equal on a yards per play basis.  Going into the Ohio State game, it was plausible that Purdue could have been 5-1 or 6-0 had they been particularly lucky instead of unlucky (and no, this is not a stretch - just look at Iowa, which is 7-0 despite close shaves against Northern Iowa and Arkansas State) - at which point I would still have picked Ohio State but it wouldn't have seemed like such a colossal upset.

So, in that sense, it was about time that one of Purdue's opponents handed them a game, and Ohio State did just that, with 5 turnovers.  And clearly, Vegas has recognized that despite similar records, Purdue has been far more competitive than the Illini - having been outscored by just 4 points on the season whereas the Illini have been outscored by 71.  Even with a new head coach and new QB, Purdue has had a rejuvenated pass attack this year, with Joey Elliott averaging 7.1 yards per pass attempt against the 6.3 of Curtis Painter last season.  Their team rushing statistics also look better since Elliott has more scrambling ability - though it's probably a wash given that sacks are included in team rushing totals.  Purdue has been slightly improved on defense from last year, primarily versus the run, though their pass defense has been respectable as well.

Purdue's pitfall, of course, has been turnovers, with 12 fumbles lost and 11 interceptions thrown, leaving them -7 in turnover margin on the season even after the +2 performance against Ohio State.  They actually have 23 turnovers to just 13 by Illinois but have also forced 16 turnovers while the Illini have forced just 9.  Part of Purdue's troubles have been bad luck, as they have lost 12 of their 17 fumbles - and fumble recovery rate is almost completely random.  But even so, 17 fumbles in 7 games is a big number, as is 11 interceptions.

So although Purdue is certainly the superior team to Illinois in terms of moving the ball up and down the field, they have already lost to inferior teams (Northern Illinois, Northwestern) thanks to their issues with turnovers and general inconsistency.  In other words, there is hope for the Illini yet, but if Purdue makes mistakes, Illinois will have to be able to take advantage of them - something they have not yet done this season.

Wednesday, October 21, 2009

Yards per Point

For my post yesterday, I calculated the average yards per point for NCAA football teams.  In 2008, teams averaged a point for every 13.7 yards gained, or a touchdown for every 96 yards.  Obviously, the average touchdown drive is shorter than 96 yards but every time a team drives 75 yards and only kicks a field goal or turns the ball over in the red zone, their yards per point is significantly hit.  On the other hand, teams can score touchdowns without even touching the ball on offense.  What it sums up to is that the average college football team can expect a touchdown for every 96 yards of offense.

Obviously, since this is an average, some teams will be more successful at converting yards into points than others.  Last year, the three most efficient teams in converting yards into points on offense were Florida, Oklahoma and Utah.  Perhaps not surprisingly, Florida and Oklahoma played for the national championship and Utah completed an undefeated season with a Sugar Bowl upset against Alabama. 

The question, of course, is whether converting yards into points is a skill or a matter of luck.  Something like yards per point will depend a lot on turnover margins and special teams, which tend to swing from year to year.  On the other hand, I would expect some level of skill to be involved, especially for the better teams in football.  That said, the top 5 teams in converting yards into points in 2008 have seen their yards per point ratio increase (get worse) by an average of 3.3 points in 2009.  Meanwhile, the bottom 5 teams in converting yards into points in 2008 have seen their ratios drop by an average of 3.4 points in 2009.

So what does this mean for Illinois football?  After ranking 92nd nationally in yards per point last year (thus making a potentially great offense rather inconsistent), the Illinois offense is 119th out of 120 teams this year (21.7 yards per point).  Illinois is averaging just one touchdown for every 152 yards of offense!  The good news is that with a total that low, simple bad luck comes into play.  So the Illini offense is not quite as bad as it has looked thus far this year.  With an average number of yards per point, they would be averaging 27 points per game instead of 16.5 - but an average number of yards per point is still a bit much to expect from a Ron Zook team. 

Now in most of Illinois' games this wouldn't have made a difference.  Based purely on raw yardage, they would still have been projected to lose all the games they did.  And in truth, their yardage totals are misleading considering they have racked up a lot of 'garbage time' yardage on offense in their last three games.  But the game against Indiana could very much have gone a different way if the Illini had gone up 14-13 instead of seeing Juice fumble at the 5 yard line.  Illinois actually had a superior success rate against the Hoosiers but was somewhat less explosive on a per-play basis.  Thus, I don't think that Illinois is a worse team than Indiana - considering that Indiana was at home, they are probably about even.  That may be damning with faint praise, but it offers some hope to a team that has yet to record a win against an FBS opponent.

So the good news is that the Illini offense will likely regress to the mean a bit and score a few more points than they've been scoring.  The bad news is that Ron Zook's teams have consistently undershot the average on yards per point for offense, with the offense averaging just 17.1 yards per point during his five-year tenure, and never finishing above the national mean.  Thus, although this year's team is getting unlucky, it is also a reflection on Zook's coaching that the offense has been consistently inefficient at converting yardage into points .

Tuesday, October 20, 2009

Illini Football Season Statistics

Although my analysis of the Illini football season has been statistically-oriented, I have not delivered on my promise to offer exclusive Illini statistics.  Well fear no more! 

Over at Rock M Nation, a Missouri sports blog, the proprietor, Bill Connelly, has developed a system for rating the success of college teams, units and players that has also made its way into columns at ESPN and Football Outsiders.  I am going to do something similar to analyze the Illini, though not quite as advanced, for the sake of saving time. 

Basically, there are two metrics that I want to look at.  One is yards per play, which I am converting into points per play based on an average ratio of 1 point for every 13.8 yards (Note that this reflects projected points scored, not actual points scored, which is something I will discuss more tomorrow).  The other is success rate, which measures whether each play was a success.  I'm using Connelly's criteria for what constitutes a success, namely:

1st down: A play that gains 50% of required yardage is a success
2nd down: A play that gains 70% of required yardage is a success
3rd and 4th down: A play that gains 100% of required yardage is a success

Then, similar to what Connelly does, I added the team's projected points per play and success rate together - thus capturing the pure scoring rate of an offense while also capturing its play-to-play consistency (i.e., are they more dependent on one big play to score or a series of smaller plays). 

Now, for some season statistics!










I don't have a lot of data yet to put into context exactly what these numbers mean but suffice it to say that the .835 figure for the Illinois offense is probably average but the .935 figure for the defense is pretty bad (and the numbers would look a lot worse if not for Illinois' beatdown of Illinois State).  Illinois' success rate on offense (44.5%) is not that much worse than the success rate of their opponents (46.6%), but their opponents get significantly more points per play, reflecting the Illini's lack of big play ability.  Illinois has actually outperformed their opponents on the season in the run game - but again, that is skewed because of the 400 yard rushing performance against Illinois State.  Still, the run game has largely been a wash for the Illini.  Where they have been beaten badly is in the passing game.

In performing this play-by-play analysis, I counted all sacks as pass plays (since that's what they are!), which means that Illinois actually averages more points per rush than per pass, which is rare.  Generally, you would expect the passing game to have a higher points per play value but a lower success rate due to incomplete passes.  Instead, the Illini passing game has been ineffective all around with a low success rate (37.5%) and a poor ratio of points per play.  On the other side of the ball, the secondary has been regularly torched this year, yielding a 1.016 S&P+ (using Connelly's terminology for the time being - though it is not exactly the same thing).  Apart from the Penn State game, the run defense has been pretty good but the strategy of putting the corners into loose coverage has clearly not been an effective one.

Tomorrow, I will show why the Illinois offense has been rather unlucky this year and why the Illinois-Indiana game was closer than it looked, perhaps giving some positive signs going ahead.

Monday, October 19, 2009

Indiana 27, Illinois 14 and Thoughts on the Ron Zook Era

With yet another baffling and embarrassing loss, it's safe to say that Ron Zook is on the hot seat.  I watched this game from start to finish, and it is clear that Illinois is the worst team in the Big 10.  The final game statistics give some false signs of hope, but 148 of Illinois' 443 yards of offense came in the fourth quarter, after they had already fallen behind 27-7 (and even then it took the Illini 29 plays to get those yards).  Sure, Illinois had a chance to go ahead 14-13 before the critical Juice fumble on the 5, but only because Indiana had gone into the red zone three times and come out with just three points.  And it's hard to even give much credit to the Illini for stopping Indiana in the red zone given that the Hoosiers missed two field goals and had their running back fall down on 4th and 1 when he probably would have scored a touchdown.

The Illini offense was average, with a solid touchdown drive in the first half, but simply could not put anything together consistently until it was too late.  But after a nice performance in the second half against Michigan State, the defense was lost yet again, surrendering 482 yards of offense on 6.8 yards per snap.  Most galling, Indiana QB Ben Chappell threw for a career high 333 yards and 3 touchdowns.  I know the defense is young, and has only gotten younger due to a wave of injuries (LB Martez Wilson, CB Miami Thomas, and now, S Donsay Hardeman).  But it would be nice if the coaching staff would put them in a position to try and make plays.  Instead, they run the same vanilla 4-3 scheme every week with the corners 10 yards off the receivers and almost no blitzing.  Predictably, there is no pass rush and the team gets picked apart with short passes.   The other huge negative about the 'bend but don't break' style of defense is that the Illini seemingly never force turnovers.  Illinois is a remarkably bad -38 in turnover margin during the Ron Zook era and has NEVER had a positive turnover margin on the season.  This is incredible given that turnover margin is notoriously inconsistent from year to year.

I appreciate Zook's enthusiasm but it's time for me to admit that my optimism has blinded me.  Admittedly, there are more problems with this team than just coaching.  After all, Zook did coach a team to the Rose Bowl just two years ago - so it's not true that he is totally incompetent.  But what is true, both at Florida and at Illinois, is that Zook's teams consistently underachieve.  And for all his vaunted recruiting, the product on the field this year simply isn't all that talented.  The defense is young and thanks to injuries, has gotten even younger.  The offense has failed to gel.  Zook brings the players in but hasn't shown an ability to keep those players on the team or to help them develop their potential.

The root of the problem  is that Zook thinks that everything will be solved if the team just plays harder.  I have collected a series of quotations from Zook this year, which are rather damning.

"This is going to end when we decide it's going to end" - Ron Zook after the Indiana loss
"I don't think we're as far away as everyone thinks" - Ron Zook after the Michigan State loss
"I'm not sure this is the right thing to do, but it'll give us a change and we'll see" - Ron Zook after announcing that Eddie McGee would start against Michigan State
"Obviously, again, we didn't play the way we are capable of playing" - Zook after the Penn State loss
"We're in a little slump now for whatever reason and we're going to have to play our way out of it" - Zook after the Ohio State loss
"We didn't play the way we've practiced" - Zook after the Missouri loss

What's terrifying is that Ron Zook is apparently unable to see or admit that this team just isn't very good.  He still thinks that the problem is just that they aren't playing hard enough or putting it all together.  If they were playing well some weeks and not others, I could see his point, but that isn't the case.  They have been consistently outclassed by all of their opponents apart from Illinois State.  This is not a team that isn't playing hard.  This is a team that isn't very good.  That alone is a huge knock on Zook, but the biggest red flag is when the head coach can't recognize that he doesn't have a very good team.  Ron Zook is unwilling or incapable of properly analyzing the players around him.  He thinks that everything is a matter of motivation, which it isn't.  Is it a wonder that his recruits haven't developed when all Zook apparently does is tell them to play harder?  Sorry, Ron, but this season should be your last.

Friday, October 16, 2009

Indiana Outlook

Well, I ran the same simulation I ran last week, and unsurprisingly, Illinois' bowl odds have plummeted after another lackluster loss.  Just a week ago, the Illini projected to be a 6 point favorite against Indiana but Vegas is finally ditching its high preseason expectations for Illinois and has moved them to just a 2 point favorite (Actually, the line has moved up to 3.5 over the last day - this is a good sign!).  Correspondingly, Illinois' bowl odds have fallen from 35.2% to 13.6% in my simulation.  It's still not impossible but with a mean simulated finish of 4-8, the more pressing question may be whether Ron Zook will still be coaching Illinois this time next year. 

It's past time to throw out the preseason expectations.  The offense has been much worse than expected and the defense, the main question mark coming into the season, has shown why it was a question mark.  But if Illinois is going to win any games this year, now is a good time to get started.  The young defense played a lot better in the second half against Michigan State.  Arrelious Benn is healthy.  And best of all, they are playing an opponent who hasn't looked a whole lot more impressive than they have.  I'm calling for a strong, consistent performance from the defense and Juice hooking up with Benn for a long touchdown pass. 

Pick: Illinois 24, Indiana 17

Thursday, October 15, 2009

Indiana Preview

Indiana has historically been the weakest team in the Big 10, so it's not too surprising that Illinois, even at 1-4, has been posted as a road favorite by Vegas.  Yet at the same time, Illinois is only favored to win by two points over a team that was throttled 47-7 by Virginia last week.  The Illini are 0-4 against the spread this year and as such, Vegas has brought the line on this game way down from where it would have been just a few weeks ago. 

So what can we expect from the Hoosiers?  They got off to a 3-0 start, but only thanks to the kind of pathetic nonconference schedule I wish Illinois would play, with narrow wins over Western Michigan, FCS member Eastern Kentucky and a more resounding win against Akron.  Their most impressive game of the season by far was a 36-33 loss at Michigan where they actually outgained the Wolverines 467-372 but lost on a late touchdown drive by Michigan QB Tate Forcier.  Based on that performance, Indiana probably would have been favored against the Illini except for last week when they were torched by an improving Virginia team, dropping them to 3-3 on the season.

Even without QB Kellen Lewis (kicked off the team due to disciplinary problems), Indiana has a decent passing offense behind QB Ben Chappell, who is averaging 6.8 yards per pass attempt.  Their running game hasn't been as impressive due largely to the immobility of Chappell but the top two running backs, Demetrius McCray and Darius Willis, have been decently productive. 

Where the team has really struggled is in the secondary, giving up 8.0 yards per pass attempt (even worse than Illinois!).  This flaw became all too visible for Hoosier fans when embattled Virginia QB Jameel Sewell threw for 308 yards in three quarters and Virginia racked up 536 yards of offense.  The Hoosier secondary was also embarassing against FCS Eastern Kentucky, whose quarterbacks went 17-26 for 278 yards in a 19-13 loss. 

Even with their poor secondary, Indiana has been slightly better than Illinois on a per-play basis this year.  The teams have been the same on offense, both averaging 5.2 yards per play, but Indiana has had a superior rush defense and thus has surrendered 5.5 yards per play versus Illinois' 6.0.  That said, Illinois has played a significantly tougher schedule and probably has more talent.  We still don't know for sure who will be starting at QB for the Illini, but I'm guessing it will be Juice, and if so, he and Arrelious Benn will really need to take advantage of a weak Indiana secondary for the Illini to win.